Focus Friday: Too Famous To Feed?
Posted by Haute Mama HeidiJul 16
First there was Too Posh To Push – the elite set of Mums, led by the likes of Liz Hurley and Victoria Beckham, who opted to give
birth to their babies by elective c-section, not for medical reasons but simply because, well, they were supposedly too posh to push. Now it looks like we’re about to witness the emergence of a whole new category of celebrity-inspired parenting: Too Famous To Feed.
Celeb mum Denise Van Outen is the poster girl for this new movement. She gave up breastfeeding after three weeks according to an interview published in the current edition of SHE magazine. DvO, who gave birth to daughter Betsy in May, reportedly said: ”I probably should have persevered a bit longer than three weeks. But I’ve had paparazzi sat outside every day since I had her and I can’t be sitting in Starbucks and breastfeeding, because they’re taking pictures.”
Er, that would be the same Denise Van Outen who seemed to spend most of the ’90’s posing scantily-clad for lads magazines? Oh look, and who repeated the experience just recently with Melanie Sykes, to publicise her role as host of The Five O’Clock Show on Channel 4. And the very same woman who thought nothing of working out with a personal trainer in a very public park in front of the paparazzi just weeks before she gave birth. I don’t know about you, but I’d much rather be papped discreetly nursing a newborn than stripped to my undies or panting my way round a park in jogging pants.

Now let’s get one thing straight. We’re not having a go at Denise for giving up breastfeeding. According to SHE she also hinted at other factors which influenced her decision to switch to bottle-feeding, saying she wasn’t producing enough milk and that her husband, Lee, wanted to be able to feed their daughter too. The last thing a new Mum needs is to be criticised or judged for her decisions – coping with a newborn is a monumental challenge on its own, without anyone sticking their oar in and telling you you’re doing it wrong. Far be it from us to bitch about breastfeeing vs bottle-feeding. As long as you feed your baby, you’re doing your job as far as we’re concerned.
What irks us about this storm (in a bra cup) is the idea that being seen breastfeeding is something to be embarrassed about. Um, hello? Has no-one told Denise about Haute Mama’s range of nursing covers and ponchos? We’re feeling feisty over the fact that breastfeeding has been getting a bad press of late. It’s neither creepy nor impractical and while women who really ought to know better keep implying that it is, scores of new mums are probably being put off breastfeeding altogether. And that’s no better than bullying or guilt-tripping them into it. We’d like to see some balance in the breastfeeding debate, and we’d love to hear celeb mums extolling its virtues and talking about it like it’s a normal part of motherhood.
Denise is also quoted as saying: “Another time, I was at the back of a really long queue at the Post Office to get Betsy a passport, knowing that in the next half-hour she was going to wake up and cry, wanting a feed.” Most new mums have been there, and it must be seriously horror-inducing when you’ve got the added factor of strangers scrutinising your every reaction just because you’re a celeb, but maybe there’s also something to be said for the days of the babymoon, when new mums prioritised languishing at home, getting to know their new bundles instead of dashing off to Starbucks or the Post Office. We’re not saying mums should be housebound – I was out having coffee within 24 hours of having my second baby and felt all the more human for being able to do so – but I sometimes wonder if we’re just way too keen to resume normal life, and too reluctant to slow down long enough to treasure our new life with a newborn. After all, Starbucks will probably always be there. Our babies won’t.
13 comments
Comment by HauteMama on July 16, 2010 at 8:15 am
So ladies, what do you reckon?
Comment by Kerrie on July 16, 2010 at 12:18 pm
Agree wholeheartedly with article and the fact that the world seems to imagine every breastfed baby is attached to some sort of a sex toy…be proud to be pregnant and show your bump and be proud to continue the wonderful start in life that breastfeeding gives your precious bundle! I fed all 3 of mine in various public places but never made a fuss and just continued chatting, eating or answering the front door with my calm and content baby attached. Its bad that celebs have the power to change opinions but they do.. this is not good for breastfeeding and therefore very very bad for babies and the future health of the world.
Comment by Lisa on July 16, 2010 at 1:30 pm
I think it’s so sad that we have yet another celeb “breastfeeding is icky and inconvenient” story in the media. I wondered the same thing – could she not use a nursing cover? (I had one and used it the first few times I breastfed in public.) And why is she fine with being photographed semi naked, but not being papped with a mostly covered breast and a newborn in front of it?
There’s a fairly recent gov’t incentive that gives all pregnant mums a sum of money at around the 28 week mark (think… See more it was £170?) as part of their Healthy Start initiative. Supposedly, it’s so mums can eat healthily in pregnancy. Why not put that money towards breastfeeding support instead? They also offer all mums vouchers in pregnancy and after the birth that are specifically for fruit, veg, and milk – including infant formula. There just isn’t enough being done to encourage mums to breastfeed.
(Usual disclaimer: my first child was formula fed, so I’m not at all “anti” formula feeding mums.)
Comment by HauteMama on July 16, 2010 at 1:53 pm
Fabulous comments, ladies, thanks for kicking things off!
Couldn’t agree more… although Lisa something troubles me about the thought of effectively paying mums to breastfeed, although I don’t really know why. Hmm.
Comment by Hen on July 16, 2010 at 2:22 pm
I wonder if its because celebs see breastfeeding as getting in the way of getting their ultra sleek bodies back and attending various parties?
Comment by Chantel on July 16, 2010 at 5:47 pm
sad that Denise gave up breastfeeding, it can be done so discreetly no matter where you are, I fed all three of mine anywhere and everywhere, but i guess it is hard when you are being followed around by photographers 24/7. Hope some celebs who have loved breastfeeding speak up to balance it out and that mummies to be are not put off – it is incredible to be able to do and so convenient – I loved never having to carry around bottles or worrying about how i would get them heated!
Comment by Lizzzombie on July 16, 2010 at 6:45 pm
What I don’t get is that ultimately breast feeding burns calories (ie. MAKES YOU THIN). Obviously its great for the baby etc, but its also fab for your figure.
Lots of celebrity Mums do mention that one of the reasons they lost their baby weight so fast is due to successfully breast feeding for a longer period of time.
Unfortunately the reverse happened when I BF my own son. After loosing tons of weight during the pregnancy due to severe heartburn, I piled it on whilst breast feeding as the 500 extra calories I was told which it burnt off daily were ploughed back into excessive eating of flapjack. (went a bit mad with the baking in the first few months). But next time round it will be different!
Comment by Fliss on July 17, 2010 at 10:05 am
Hmmm, I never got to stage of being confronted with how to breastfeed in public – was snowed in for first few weeks and then abscess put end to hard work before we made it to starbucks… but know I would have been happy to do it though. I’m sure its different & difficult for anyone in the limelight being followed by cameras when they’re out and about but would be nice if they used their position to highlight breastfeeding in a positive way – that its not always easy but a great thing to do and definitely something that can be done in public. You’d think they’d love the attention. Off the top of my head can’t think of any celebs who did breastfeed in public?? Lizzzombie any chance of selling flapjacks through Haute Mama yummy!!!
Comment by Haute Mama on July 17, 2010 at 10:26 am
Hen – I think you’re spot on there that getting your boobs out interferes with getting your face in the papers. Sad but true.
Chantel – exactly! What could be easier?
Lizzzombie – I know, I’m almost tempted to have another baby purely in the hopes that if I breastfeed for long enough I might end up skinny?!
Fliss -wow, snowed in with a newborn, I bet that was an interesting time! Jennifer Garner and Christina Aguilera have both spoken out about positively about breastfeeding, but I can’t think of any celebs in the UK who have, either. I wonder if it’s partly because the US is better equipped with nursing rooms? Great idea re the flapjacks! We could start a whole new line in feeding mums who are feeding…!
Comment by Kelly on July 17, 2010 at 10:22 pm
Not quite sure about this but I think I remember reading somewhere that Terri Hatcher said ‘I breastfed for 2 years. You don’t want to see me without my bra on.’ Which is kind of a mixed message … but you have to admire her honesty. Having breastfed three, I can relate!!! Yay to celebs who challenge the obstacles to feeding in public, whoever they may be …
Comment by Haute Mama on July 18, 2010 at 9:17 am
Well said, Kelly!
Comment by admin on July 18, 2010 at 9:51 am
I don’t think that Denise Van Outen did herself any favours by claiming that she quit breastfeeding because of the pressure from the paparazzi. It’s likely that it was a big factor but I think she could have been a bit more savvy about her statement. She probably does get hounded by photographers and with a new baby that’s no fun, but using that as the primary reason and then following with ‘oh and my husband wanted to feed her too and I wasn’t producing enough milk’ seems a bit lame to be honest. Having struggled through nursing two kids I would be much happier to hear a celeb say ‘I tried it for three weeks, I’ve done my best but I am just too sore, not producing enough milk, baby is not satisfied, etc… and I need to be a happy mom not breast-feeding, not a miserable mess struggling with something that is just not working for me’.
Comment by Pip on July 19, 2010 at 3:17 pm
I think DvO was probably looking for what she felt would be perceived as an “acceptable” reason for giving up breast feeding. There are not many of us who are brave enough to just admit that we hated breast feeding and gave up (or didn’t even start) out of personal preference. The pro-breast feeding lobby is so fierce and furious (and with so little scientific reasoning – in the Western world though not in the developing world) that those of us who didn’t/on’t breast feed are usually made to feel little better than child-molesters. I submitted to pummelling and coaxing and hours of rather aggressive manual persuasion from my “lactation counsellor” at the hospital after my daughter was born – meaning that I felt justified in saying that “I tried but failed” and still I was vilified by other mothers. If DvO had said she just hated it then more articles would be being written about the fact that she was doing “the wrong thing” and that somehow as a “celeb” she has a responsibility to do “the right thing”. I think it likely that her reasons were nothing like the reasons she’s portrayed but that she feels she can’t be honest about her reasons – which is sad.
(Oh and by the way, I lost all the baby weight without breast feeding. Many of my friedns breast fed for months or even years and gained steadily throughout. I think exercise and diet has more relevance than method of feeding….